Context and Influences on Nutritional Choices

The transformation towards sustainable food systems is at the center of the international debate to respond to current climatic, social, and economic challenges. For decades, the idea prevailed that change depended primarily on consumer education, with the expectation that citizens would make ethical choices based solely on information campaigns. However, in daily life, choices are not purely rational but are influenced by physical, economic, political, and socio-cultural factors that make up the Food Environment. This is defined by the High Level Panel of Experts (HLPE, 2017) as the “…physical, economic, political and socio-cultural context in which consumers interact with the food system to make their decisions about acquiring, preparing and consuming food.” It acts as an “interface” and mediator: it translates consumer demand into signals for producers and, conversely, shapes choices through the availability and accessibility of products. Currently, food environments often favor unhealthy diets; the goal is to reverse this trend by creating contexts where sustainable and healthy products are the most accessible, desirable, and affordable.
The transformation towards sustainable food systems is a topic that has animated the international debate for some years. It arouses great interest due to the multiplicity and heterogeneity of the proposed solutions, which are a consequence of the different types of food systems existing on our planet. This latter aspect highlights the complexity researchers and policymakers face when designing policies and interventions tailored to a specific context.
To achieve greater sustainability and healthiness across different types of food systems, it is crucial to consider them in their entirety. This means accepting the close interrelation—hitherto largely overlooked—between consumption and production, while simultaneously analyzing the various elements that can be acted upon. Among these, the one receiving increasing attention within food policies is the Food Environment (HLPE, 2017).
In recent years, the prevailing approach has emphasized the responsibility of consumer choices, expecting individuals to make the right food decisions in environmental, social, or ethical terms based on simple information campaigns aimed at encouraging sustainable diets and lifestyles. Unfortunately, however, in everyday life, consumer behavior is not based solely on the information received. Instead, it is tied to physical, economic, political, social, and cultural factors, the majority of which individuals are simply subjected to.
The combination of these factors forms the food environment within which the consumer acts and makes their choices regarding food. In summary, it represents the “interface” between the Food Supply Chain, the consumer, and diets.
The implications based on the creation of sustainable Food Environments currently represent a strategic approach to the transformation of food systems. This is based on the belief that our food choices and their consequent impact are guided not by the consumer, but by the contexts in which they are made. Consequently, for the sustainable transformation of food systems, it is necessary to act on those social, political, economic, commercial, and technological elements that can enable consumers to practice sustainable and healthy diets[3].
Furthermore, the food environment, by positioning itself between the needs of consumers and those of producers, transfers food demand patterns to production methods. This means that if demand is directed towards organic farming products, naturally the supply, and therefore production, will adapt to this request, affecting the production method to be adopted.
On the other hand, food production also acts on the food environment as it influences the availability of food and its characteristics related to the impact on natural resources and climate change, social and cultural aspects, human health, and animal welfare.
The diagram shown in Figure 1 illustrates how, theoretically, the creation of a Food Environment—the meeting point between the supply chain and the consumer—is regulated by physical, economic, socio-cultural, and political factors. It is fundamentally important not only in shaping the food choices of citizens but also in mediating the needs between consumers and producers, because it translates sustainable demand patterns into production criteria by determining the products demanded, their production standards, and the selling price. On the other hand, sustainable production influences the Food Environment as it determines the general availability of food products, their environmental, social, and health characteristics, as well as animal welfare.
From an intervention perspective, it is therefore fundamental to incentivize the desirability of sustainable products, creating new and better needs for the consumer.
Therefore, creating sustainable food environments means ensuring that foods and beverages that contribute to healthy and sustainable diets are the most available, physically and economically accessible, appealing, widely advertised, and popular[4].
Furthermore, an ethics of consumption is necessary, one that links individual choices to the well-being of the community. Such an ethic cannot be imposed from above but must leverage the existing cultural resources in each territory. Cultural food patterns like the Mediterranean Diet can facilitate the transformation towards sustainable consumption by associating the need for change with cultural identity (Brunori, 2022).
Numerous policies and programs aimed at making the food environment sustainable have been implemented worldwide, although the majority of those investigated in the literature have focused on high-income countries and less on low- and middle-income ones.

Most of these measures, which should always be accompanied by social, economic, and infrastructural policies to ensure individuals can benefit from sustainable food environments and producers can participate in them, have focused on the following axes:
a. Availability and physical and economic access to food b. Food quality and safety c. Promotion, advertising, and information.
a. Availability, physical and economic access to food Food availability does not guarantee food and nutritional security, as food may be available but not accessible from either a physical or economic point of view.
The former depends on geographical or technical conditions that can limit access and distribution of food, as can happen, for example, in landlocked countries or small islands, as well as the lack of adequate infrastructure in some low- and middle-income countries.
Economic access to food reflects the relative cost of food compared to a household’s income and purchasing power. Food prices, taxes, and food subsidies affect the economic accessibility of food and influence consumption patterns. Naturally, ensuring that healthier foods are cheaper and less healthy ones are more expensive is one way to encourage consumers to buy certain foods over others. However, in most places around the world, this is not the case.
b. Food quality and safety The characteristics of a food that influence its value and make it acceptable or desirable to the consumer include: size, shape, color, texture, flavor, composition, as well as the way the food is produced or processed (i.e., “organic,” “cage-free,” “antibiotic-free”).
Foods have an impact on human health, and for this reason, standards and controls exist to protect consumers from unsafe foods.
The lack of storage and transport through the cold chain in many low- and middle-income countries can make perishable foods unsafe to eat and increase the risk of transmitting pathogens and consequent foodborne illnesses, in addition to food loss and waste.
Food quality and safety can influence consumption patterns through changes in consumer preferences or the economic accessibility of foods.
c. Food Promotion, Advertising, and Information Retail outlets and markets promote food to consumers through various means (advertising, social marketing, billboards, radio and television advertising, etc.) that serve to influence food acceptability, consumer preferences, purchasing behavior, and consumption patterns, both negatively and positively.
In addition to nutritional labels, national food-based dietary guidelines represent another important resource for consumers. They provide recommendations based on the latest available evidence regarding food and nutrient composition, adapted to the national context. While they might not directly lead to changes in dietary patterns, they can influence consumer preferences and inform both food chain actors and policymakers.
3. Role of Innovation and Technology in Supporting the Food Environment Technological innovations are increasingly becoming part of people’s daily lives, and in focusing on food environments—which represent all the elements that surround us in our daily reality—one cannot overlook the role that these, and digitalization in particular, have played.
Consequently, the concept of the Digital Food Environment has begun to spread, understood as the online ecosystem where information, services, and products related to food are made accessible through digital platforms. This includes websites, mobile applications, social media, e-commerce platforms, and virtual communities that influence users’ food choices, accessibility, and eating behaviors. We can also consider it as an augmented experience of the food environment through digital technologies, ranging from online food education campaigns, interactions on social networks and social media, to apps and platforms linked to food delivery services.
In this way, users can obtain a wide range of information and knowledge through online articles, videos, and interactive platforms, covering topics such as the sustainability of natural resources, the traditions and food culture of populations, the economy of territories, and health and nutrition.
These digital platforms, by offering e-commerce opportunities, facilitate the online sale of food products and allow users to purchase from local farmers, grocery stores, and specialized natural food retailers. They offer cooking tutorials, food education courses, and meal planning, helping users develop skills and knowledge for sustainable and healthy eating. Furthermore, social media, social networks, and specialized online forums promote food-centric communities where experiences, recipes, and tips can be shared, creating a sense of belonging and mutual support. The digital food environment thus fosters the building of communities around food-related interests, enabling people to exchange ideas and support each other in adopting more sustainable and healthy lifestyles. With technological advancements, many digital food platforms provide personalized advice based on dietary, cultural, religious preferences, and users’ sustainability and health goals. In this way, the digital food environment encourages people to make informed and sustainable food choices.
Digital food environments can improve access to sustainable diets, particularly in underserved areas, by connecting consumers with local farms, grocery stores, and meal delivery services.
Finally, the digital space helps to improve public understanding of food policies, enabling stakeholders to advocate for healthier food environments through online campaigns and petitions.
However, such technologies inevitably add further complexity to an already complicated food environment that aims to shape consumer food choices. Indeed, having gained significant centrality in individuals’ daily lives and, consequently, in their food environments, they also present a downside: the substantial impacts that social media marketing and influencers can have on the consumption of unhealthy food products by vulnerable consumers, such as minors, or the promotion of unhealthy diets by dubious pseudo-nutritionists.
From this perspective, significant challenges arise that must be adequately considered by legislators.
The digital food environment represents a crucial infrastructure for promoting sustainable and healthy diets, improving food accessibility, informing, and fostering community engagement around food.
With the continuous evolution of digital technologies, the digital food environment will play an increasingly significant role in transforming food systems and promoting sustainability, health, and well-being in communities worldwide.
In recent years, but particularly during the period when the whole world experienced social restrictions related to the impact of Covid-19, digital technologies have strongly accelerated the transformation within the food environment by changing how individuals shop and order online, receive food, search for recipes, and identify diets to follow.
In particular, apps for ordering and delivering food (over 200 million users of online meal delivery platforms in Europe in 2022) and those that suggest the best personalized diets are among the most downloaded food-related apps by users.
Digital technologies, through websites and apps, also allow food retailers to offer new digital services for purchasing and delivering groceries and meals, as well as suggesting new recipes.
They also enable the development of direct relationships between producers and consumers, bypassing retail sales.
Technology, therefore, represents a powerful driver of change that acts on both the external dimensions of the Food Environment—such as food availability, price levels, product properties, marketing, and regulation—and on personal dimensions, as it is linked to the convenience, desirability, and accessibility of food.
Underlying this is the conviction that food environments, being the interface between the value chain and consumption, are influenced by numerous and very different components. Therefore, it is necessary to act on an ecosystem of activities at different levels supported by social, economic, and infrastructural policies.
In reconstructing the food environment, it is therefore necessary to apply policies that involve numerous actors at various levels: from European and global institutions to national governments, local and regional authorities, down to farmers, fishermen, food processing industries, restaurateurs, schools, hospitals, and different types of canteens, etc.
