Position Paper Matrix
| Interdependent dimensions Food environment | Strategic Objective | Critical issues and needs for the improvement of responsible consumption (sustainability) of national fish products | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a) Physical and economic availability and access | 1) Improving the availability and physical and economic access of domestic seafood products | Physical availability and accessibility | a) Insufficient organisation and coordination between wholesale markets | ||
| b) Insufficient integration and contractualization within the fish supply chain to make the product available in adequate times and places and difficulties in identifying the role and operation of forms of aggregation (POs) in the fisheries sector in order to make the market more efficient by overcoming the difficulties of product aggregation. | |||||
| c) Lack of clearly differentiated commercial channels based on price, quantity and quality, capable of responding to the needs of different consumption contexts (for example, in school canteens there are often no supply models that combine moderate costs, nutritional quality and food education, which are essential to accustom children to a balanced and sustainable diet from childhood), average prices in collective canteens where volumes and diversification of the diet are important) – “Premium” prices in catering with a higher quality level and where I can choose the quality product). | |||||
| d) Strong pressure on fish stocks affecting the availability, access, nutritional quality and sustainability of food | |||||
| e) Poor organization of the offer, which does not allow to adequately enhance the qualitative and quantitative availability of the fish product, both in the retail trade and in the catering sector. | |||||
| f) Insufficient processing of the fish product, which limits its availability for collective catering and reduces the convenience of consumption in ready-to-eat and ready-to-cook formats. | |||||
| g) Weak local supply of small-scale fisheries and aquaculture products | |||||
| h) Weak action of governance structures intervening on agri-food systems (governments, industry, civil society) and on interactions related to consumers’ food choices | |||||
| i) Structural limits related to the reduced number of state-owned concessions for off-shore aquaculture – lack (in many Regions) of definitions of AZAs) | Affordability | ||||
| a) Reduced presence of minor fish species on the market and consequent difficulty in defining the price | |||||
| b) Low income level of less well-off consumers | |||||
| c) Tenders, based on the most advantageous offer, which do not allow the purchase of fish products with nutritional characteristics linked to health | |||||
| d) Insufficient economic support from national, regional and municipal authorities to put minor fish species and/or innovative fish products on the market and in large-scale distribution | |||||
| e) Non-existent incentives for diversifying catches and traders offering less sought-after species | |||||
| f) Lack of transparency in existing relationships between operators to improve the distribution of value creation along the supply chain and make prices more affordable | |||||
| g) Absence of financial instruments for operators who want to invest in the diversification of the activity and in particular in the first transformation of the product | |||||
| h) Strong competition of the product of non-EU origin (e.g. Norway – salmon; Turkey – Sea bass, sea bream and trout) which often benefits from subsidies with reduced protection of the national product | |||||
| i) Reduced market penetration for newly introduced (e.g. croaker) or “mature” (e.g. trout) aquaculture species | |||||
| b) Quality and safety of Italian fish food | 2) Improve quality, traceability and food safety of national fish products | a) Poor dissemination and recognition of certification and traceability processes. | |||
| b) Lack of mandatory nutritional information on the label of packaged fish products and poor enhancement of information relating to food composition and nutritional claims. | |||||
| c) Absence on the label of the date of the catch, the name of the boat or the fisherman catching. (This is for a greater relationship of trust with the consumer and to identify him in the subsequent steps of the supply chain) | |||||
| d) Insufficient clarity of information to the consumer on origin, seasonality, fishing/breeding method and difficulty for the consumer in distinguishing the sustainable national product from the imported one or from less sustainable productions. | |||||
| e) Lack of uniformity in enhancing the social sustainability of the national fish product (e.g. compliance with the CCNL and guaranteed minimum money, compliance with safety and welfare requirements, no fishing in MPAs, selective gear, reduced impact engines, etc.) | |||||
| f) Absence of information on the origin of fish products in Ho.Re.Ca. (hotel industry) | |||||
| c) Marketing, information, communication and education | 3) Improve the responsible consumption of domestic fish products | a) Need to promote sustainable consumption practices of national fish products, respecting the cultural heritage of the Mediterranean Diet and Italian Cuisine, with its fish excellences. | |||
| b) Need to promote practical and convenient recipes, with national fish products that enhance, above all, the minor species that are little consumed, including combinations with dishes of the Mediterranean Diet and Italian Cuisine | |||||
| c) Need to promote Italian fish products in educational and social contexts (e.g. school canteens and public catering); involve operators and citizens, with particular attention to young people and schools, to promote environmental and social awareness; to raise consumer awareness of the origin, quality and added value of Italian fish products through targeted campaigns. | |||||
| d) Need to provide consumers with clear information in order to make responsible sustainable choices in the consumption of Italian fish products (also in Ho.Re.Ca channels.) | |||||
| e) Enhancement of the centrality of Italian fish products in Italian cuisine, intangible heritage of UNESCO | |||||
| f) Promotion of the concept of “freshly caught” to encourage the consumption of local and seasonal Italian species | |||||
| g) Scarsa informazione sulle modalità di consumo di pesce pescato e allevato, compresi gli abbinamenti con altri prodotti alla base della Dieta Mediterranea | |||||
| h) Promotion of recipes, with national fish products, in the context of the heritage of the Mediterranean diet and Italian cuisine, to make them important and therefore “captivating” (for example, “Fast fish from the Baltic on corn cream”, i.e., cod with polenta), but also of the origin of the catch (anchovies from the Cantabrian Sea) | |||||
| i) Promotion of how fish products are cooked, and in particular minor species | |||||
| l) Promotion of the link between food, territory, seasonality, culture, local traditions, fish products and Mediterranean diet. | |||||
| m) Promotion of the Mediterranean Diet and its characteristic fish foods as a contemporary, healthy and sustainable lifestyle. | |||||
| n) Promotion of tourist routes dedicated to the knowledge of the world of fishing (stories, traditions, products, recipes, etc.) | |||||
| o) Lack of choice guidance tools (e.g. seasonality indications, enhancement of local species) that facilitate the conscious consumption of sustainable national fish products. | |||||
| p) Lack of knowledge of the products of excellence of Italian aquaculture products (sometimes also penalized by taxation): smoked, oysters, caviar | |||||
| Cross-cutting support activities and tools | Policies | a) Inadequate policies to support local market infrastructures: ports, landing services, fish markets | |||
| b) Inadequate policies to reduce losses and waste of fish products | |||||
| c) Inadequate policies to support the generational change of Italian fishermen by favoring young and women entrepreneurs | |||||
| c1) No adequate policies to allow a necessary renewal of the fishing fleet that would allow for more comfortable and safe on-board spaces, greater incentive for generational change, better on-board performance, better cold chain with the aim of fishing less but better enhancing the product | |||||
| d) Excessive pressure from European regulations with a lack of specific interventions by GSAs to protect fish stocks, ensure environmental sustainability and ensure the long-term viability of the sector. | |||||
| e) Insufficient action of governance structures intervening on agri-food systems (governments, industry, civil society) and on interactions related to consumers’ food choices | |||||
| f) Inadequate policies to improve the supply of seasonal fish products | |||||
| g) Insufficient collaboration between stakeholders of the national fish food environment | |||||
| h) Non adeguata promozione dell’associazionismo per migliorare l’organizzazione delle imprese e facilitare l’accesso ai mercati, nonche’ la corretta | |||||
| i) Lack of adequate coordination with institutional representatives at the FAO, GFCM, EC tables | |||||
| l) Need for reform of the Areas Assigned for Aquaculture and Onshore Production (AZA for both marine and inland waters) | |||||
| m) Inadequate incentives for the enhancement of extensive production and ecosystem services (carbon sequestration, protection of biodiversity, recreational services and maintenance of natural landscapes) | |||||
| n) Need for a bill on the multifunctionality of fisheries and aquaculture. (Aquaculture is not fishing, it is agriculture as it is a livestock farming system) | |||||
| o) Territorial inhomogeneity in access to sustainable national fish products, with greater difficulties in inland areas and small towns than in coastal areas. | |||||
| Training | |||||
| a) Training of young and female entrepreneurs in the national fishing sector to encourage generational change, through the implementation of tutoring programs with particular attention to the start-up of new businesses and support services for start-ups. | |||||
| b) Training on improving the quality, traceability and food safety of national fish products | |||||
| c) Encourage apprenticeship, which is difficult to apply to fishing, even if the law does not prohibit it. | |||||
| Digitalization | |||||
| a) Administrative simplification and technological innovation | |||||
| b) Pleasure and desirability of eating Italian fish products through digital platforms, the preferred tool for young people to place orders (e.g., Glovo) | |||||
| c) Creation of digital marketplaces and e-commerce platforms to encourage direct sales and reduce dependence on intermediaries, through the digitization of sales activities and the promotion, through online platforms and targeted marketing tools, of zero-kilometer consumption models; promotion of integrated models combining fishing, aquaculture and complementary activities such as fish tourism, direct sales and processing of products, to increase their competitiveness and diversification | |||||
| d) Promotion on digital platforms of the health, cultural and culinary characteristics of Italian fish productions | |||||
| Scientific research and innovation | |||||
| a) Blue circular economy development: implementation of business models (circular supply chain, extension of product life, sharing platform, product as a service). | |||||
| b) Reduction of losses and waste of fish products by promoting recycling and recovery. | |||||
| c) Development of application of innovative technologies at the service of the fisherman | |||||
| d) Development of projects for the functional and productive restoration of extensive environments (e.g. valley farming) and economic recognition of the ecosystem services offered to mitigate climate change | |||||
| e) Reduction of the vulnerability of the national fishing business system through innovation, digitization and the development of integrated commercial networks; strengthening companies’ ability to adapt to economic and climate change | |||||
OTHER CONTENTS OF THE PROJECT
